Soja soll Männerbrüste wachsen lassen? Das ist großer Quatsch.

Soy – Public Enemy Number Two

In BLOG by rosalazic4 Comments

Soy – concentrated plant power

I have already presented you the national enemy number one at the beginning of the year. Now, I’ll show you the public enemy number two: Soy. Everyone is talking about soy in the last few months. Soybeans are found in many different forms: as flour (gluten-free), sauce, tofu, chunks, milk, cream, edamame, tempeh, etc.

But soy is controversial: Men supposedly grow breasts. The cultivation of soy may contribute to the deforestation of the rain forest and it is said to be totally unhealthy, bad and harmful for humans and our climate. But what is behind this? Only a nutritional myth or is it a fact?

The positive effects of soybean consumption

Soybeans are leguminous plants and contain all essential amino acids. Therefore, they are an optimal protein source. They also contain many dietary fiber as well as vitamins (B1, B2, E, folic acid), iron and calcium. They also provide phytoestrogens, including isoflavones and lignans.

Numerous studies have shown many positive effects of eating soy and phytoestrogens. The risk of developing breast and prostate cancer can drop by as much as 50% (!). This also explains the comparatively low breast and prostate cancer rate in Asians / Asian women compared to the western world. In Asia much more soy is eaten than in Europe or the US. A 30% lower probability of developing ovarian cancer and a 50% lower probability of developing uterine cancer are the result of numerous studies focusing on a soy diet. There is also a significant link between the consumption of soy and a better bone density. Thus, it can also protect against bone fractures and osteoporosis – quite in contrast to milk consumption (to be detailed soon). Menopause symptoms can also be alleviated. Even a cup of tofu, soybeans or -milk daily can cause all these positive effects.

The consumption can have negative consequences, but only if you are allergic to soy. About 0.5% of all Americans and thus only one in 200 has an allergy – in comparison, 5% are allergic to peanuts.

But here, too, the dose makes the poison. You should not drink more than 1 liter soy milk or eat more than 1 kg of tofu daily. Everything else would lead to a one-sided, unbalanced diet.

Are men growing breasts because of eating soybeans?

Again and again, I hear that men supposedly grow breasts when eating soy. The phytoestrogens which can be found in it, are to be blamed for this. However, phytoestrogens are not normal estrogens, which are female sex hormones. Similar confusion also exists in the case of sugar alcohols, such as xylitol or erythritol. Both are chemically sugar alcohols, but they have nothing to do with the alcohol we drink.

Phytoestrogens are phytochemicals and therefore only found in plants such as soy. They protect the plant e.g. from herbivores, fungi and bacteria. In addition, they have similar effects as antioxidants, which also belong to the group of phytochemicals.

To answer the question: NO, men do not get breasts because of eating soy and phytoestrogens. This is a clear nutritional myth and not true.

If you want to avoid female sex hormones as a man, it would be more useful to avoid animal products. The consumption of meat, eggs and dairy products necessarily leads to the consumption of estrogens. Here, female hormones occur naturally. It is the female animals that give milk or lay eggs. That female sex hormones are contained in these products, should be clear to everyone. Especially in cows’ milk, dairy products and milk protein (whey protein) they can be found in quantities which should not be underestimated – soon on my blog.

No, men do not grow breast from eating soy – just fake news and alternative facts

No, men do not grow breast from eating soy – just fake news and alternative facts

Is soy always genetically modified?

I can also answer this question clearly with “No!” Soy products, which we can buy at the grocery store in Europe and partly in the US, are almost exclusively organic. In my blogpost about the Bio-Label, I have already explained that only genetically not modified products are allowed to be named as organic. To conclude: If you buy soy products in the supermarket, you can hardly buy genetically modified soy in Europe. This is different in asian supermarkets.

That’s different when dealing with soy, which is used as feed for the meat industry. In industrial livestock farms, almost exclusively genetically engineered soy is used. If you eat animal products, this genetically manipulated food gets indirectly on your plate, too. Above all, large-scale farmers swear by genetically engineered soy: It can be cultivated more uncomplicated, can carry higher yields and is more resistant to drought.

98% (!) of the world-grown soya is produced for the feed for industrial lifestock farming. Almost every second, a large area of ​​forest land is cleared to create arable land for the cultivation of feedstuff for the lifestock industry.

Only 2% of the soya cultivation is processed to tofu, soyamilk, etc. More and more German manufacturers are growing their soybeans biologically in Germany, Austria and France. So, soy bought in Germany is not only organic, but often also cultivated regionally.

Each to his own

My partner does not like the taste of soy in general. But I love eating soy products in all variants. So, I refine my salad with smoked tofu, drink my cappuccino with foamed soy-vanilla milk and my breakfast is porridge topped with soy yogurt. I like the taste of soy but I hear from many that they avoid tofu, which is however mostly a matter of preparation. Meat is only eaten seasoned or roasted, so, that’s what you should do with tofu, too. Otherwise the disappointment is inevitable.

Do you like soy and its products? Do you have a favorite tofu you would recommend? 🙂

Here are all studies for this blogpost.
You like this blogpost? Feel free to share it and stay tuned on my Facebook-Fanpage as well!

 

Share this Post

Comments

  1. I love soy and eat tofu and drink soy everyday. I have read a lot of research on soy and have found the same as you have written to be true. Well written, thank you

    1. Author

      Dear Maree,

      thank you so much for your comment! You can find really controversial stuff out there but the science comes to one conclusion: There are no harmful effects of consuming soy everyday. For hundreds of years, people in Asia follow a diet based on soy and soy products. They are the ones with the least osteoporosis and other illnesses, plus, they are amongst the healthiest people in the world.
      Thank you once again for your kind words and keep up spreading the truth,
      all the best,
      Rosa

  2. Soy in United States is mixed with genetically modified plants. You have a farmer in Iowa to grow organic right next to a GMO farmer. There is no pure strain of soy in the United States anymore. The same goes for alfalfa. And I have talked to people that live in Japan and they say their products have become tainted with the the same susceptibility.

    1. Author

      Hi Cloid,

      thanks for your comment – I really appreciate you’ve read the whole blogpost. That’s true, as long as Monsanto and all the other huge companies keep on spreading their GMO plants, it going to be tough to save organic plants. This is one of the reasons why monopolists like Monsanto should be avoided as good and as long as we can..
      Wish you all the best, Rosa

Leave a Comment